When Justice Black refers to Giboney v. Empire Storage & Ice Co. in the dissenting opinion for Tinker v. Des Moines, which kind of reasoning is he using to support his argument?

Answers

Answer 1
Answer:

Answer:

PRECEDENT

Explanation:

Answer 2
Answer:

Final answer:

Justice Black uses a form of legal reasoning known as precedent. This process involves citing previous legal decisions to support a particular argument or decision in a case. Specifically, Justice Black uses Giboney v. Empire Storage & Ice Co. as a precedent to argue against the majority decision in Tinker v. Des Moines.

Explanation:

When Justice Black refers to Giboney v. Empire Storage & Ice Co. in the dissenting opinion for Tinker v. Des Moines, he is utilizing a form of legal reasoning known as precedent. A precedent is an existing legal decision that courts turn to when making rulings on similar issues or cases. When a judge uses precedent, they are looking at past rulings to guide them in their decision-making process for the case they are currently working on.

Using precedent, or citing a previous judgment, gives a foundation to the legal argument being made. Precedent is particularly impactful in a legal dissenting opinion because it gives credibility to the argument and draws attention to past interpretations of the law that support the viewpoint being put forth.

For instance, in Tinker v. Des Moines case, Justice Black used Giboney v. Empire Storage & Ice Co. to argue that the court's allowance for symbolic speech in the form of wearing black armbands in school did, indeed, constitute a 'real' disruption of school activities – contrary to the majority opinion. He thus believed that the ruling was in violation of the precedent set by Giboney.

Learn more about Legal Precedent here:

brainly.com/question/29618654

#SPJ5


Related Questions

The student who created the graphic organizer above most likely used it during which stage of the writing process?
Which clauses in these sentences are restrictive? /The girl\ /with the golden hair\ /is the one\ /we are looking\ for./The dog\ /that ate my homework\ /is called Henry.\/I’m saving the muffins\ /that have cherries\ /for my sister.\/The smile\ /that she gave them\ /was beautiful.\
What does a thesis statement do?
A thesaurus is primarily used to look up
As a kinesthetic learner, a student should rely on which of the following during study times?

Identify the best correction of the clause fragment. Till the chimes of the clock strike midnight.
Delete “of the clock."
Add “Dance” to the beginning of the fragment.
Add “They” to the beginning of the fragment.
Change “Till” to “Until."

Answers

The correct answer is "Add 'Dance' to the beginning of the fragment".

By adding "dance", you get a complete sentence that conveys a meaning, while without it, it is a subordinate clause used to denote time at which an action might happen. This makes the sentence: "Dance till the chimes of the clock strike midnight."

Which kind of play is Shakespeare's Julius Caesar often described as?A.
a comedy
B.
a tragedy
C.
a romance
D.
a farce

Answers

It's B. tragedy, hope this helped :D

Rhythm and rhyme are synonymous. True False

Answers

False. Rhythm is how the song goes, or beats. Rhyme are words that have the same or nearly the same sound
My answer would be false because rhythm is how slow or fast your going rhyme is words that have the same sound,so in my opinion it's not a synonym!hoped I helped!!

Question 4 of 10
Which country expanded its empire the most during the Age of Discovery?

Answers

Answer:

Portugal and Spain.

Explanation:

The year 1492 was named as the ‘year of discovery’ because of the great discovery that Columbus made (the united states of America) Portugal and Spain became the early first in the Age of Exploration by signing a treaty

The Destructors," Part 2 1.
The author of "The Destructors" uses the section breaks within the text to indicate a shift in
(1 point)
time.
setting.
sequence.
perspective.
can you guys help me!!!

Answers

Final answer:

In "The Destructors," section breaks are primarily used to indicate a shift in perspective, switching between different characters' points of view.

Explanation:

In Graham Greene's short story "The Destructors," the use of section breaks within the text primarily signals a change in perspective. Throughout the story, Greene often jumps between the points of view of different characters of the Wormsley Common gang. This change is commonly denoted by a section break, offering plenty of insight into each individual character's thought process, intentions, and motivations. For instance, we get to understand the perspective of Trevor (T.), the leader of the gang, and his plan to destroy Mr. Thomas' house. Then, the section break introduces us to the perspective of other characters like Blackie and Mr. Thomas.

Learn more about Section Breaks in Literary Text here:

brainly.com/question/32930220

#SPJ12

Which literary device is apparent in the bolded lines of Viola’s speech to the captain in act II, scene IV, of Shakespeare’s Twelfth Night?

Answers

This is the line that is in bold.

VIOLA: Too well what love women to men may owe: In faith, they are as true of heart as we. My father had a daughter loved a man, As it might be, perhaps, were I a woman, I should your lordship.

The literary device that is used is that 
Analogy

Answer:Dramatic irony

Explanation: